Starcadia Quest: what to know before buying
Starcadia Quest is CMON’s science-fiction take on the Arcadia Quest system: a standalone campaign board game where a crew of heroes works through a linked series of scenarios, and where the other players at the table are not entirely on your side.
That last part is the reason to buy it or to skip it, and it is the thing most descriptions bury.
What kind of game it is
The line it belongs to is a campaign game with a competitive layer. You have scenario objectives to complete, enemies to fight and loot to carry forward, but you are also racing the other crews for the same rewards. It looks like a cooperative dungeon crawler on the table and does not play like one.
If your group wants to work together against the box, this is the wrong purchase, and the frustration will show up two sessions in. If your group enjoys being obstructed by a friend on the way to an objective, this is exactly what that mechanic feels like when it is designed in from the start rather than bolted on.
The campaign is the product
Individual scenarios are not the point. The point is the arc: heroes carry equipment and upgrades between missions, and the choices made in one scenario change what the next one looks like. Played as a series with the same group, that accumulation is what makes it worth the shelf space.
Played as a one-off with whoever is free on a Thursday, most of that value never arrives. It is worth being honest about which of those two your group actually is before spending campaign-game money.
What the miniatures are for
The figures are chibi-styled and cast in coloured plastic, which is a deliberate design decision rather than a shortcut: the game is playable and readable straight out of the box, unpainted, because the colours separate heroes from enemies without any work. Hobbyists who want to paint them can; nobody has to.
That matters more than it sounds. A campaign game that needs an evening of preparation before the first session is a campaign game that does not get played.
Where it hurts
Setup. Every scenario is laid out from scratch: tiles, enemies, tokens and objectives. On a long campaign day that is fine. On a weeknight it is a meaningful fraction of the session.
Enemy volume. Some scenarios put a lot of minions on the board at once. For experienced players that is the puzzle; for a group learning the system it reads as noise, and the first session is the wrong time to meet it.
The expansion problem. This is a CMON campaign game, which means the box you find on a shelf and the box someone backed on Kickstarter are not the same box. Exclusive heroes, extra scenarios and add-on content circulate separately and at their own prices. Check what is actually in the version you are buying rather than trusting a review, including this one, to have described your edition.
How it compares to the obvious alternatives
Against Gloomhaven, Starcadia Quest is the lighter, faster, less demanding game. Gloomhaven asks for a legacy commitment and a rules load that takes several sessions to absorb; Starcadia Quest is closer to something you can teach in one evening. It is also much less interested in being fair to you.
Against Adventure Tactics and CoraQuest, which are the sensible recommendations for younger players, the difference is the competitive layer again. Those two let a mixed-age table pull in the same direction. This one does not, and with the wrong group that is the difference between a good night and an argument.
Questions worth answering before you order
How often does your group actually meet? A campaign game bought by a group that plays every second month gets abandoned around scenario three, and the money is gone either way. This one needs a run of sessions close enough together that people remember what happened last time.
Does everyone at the table know it is competitive? Say it out loud before the box is opened. Half the bad experiences with this system come from one player arriving expecting a co-op dungeon crawler and spending the evening confused about why their friends keep getting in the way.
Who is setting it up? In practice one person ends up laying out every scenario. If that person is you, and you already resent it in the games you own, this will not be the one that changes your mind.
Which edition is on the shelf? Contents vary between the retail release and the crowdfunded versions. That is the single most common source of disappointment with CMON games bought second-hand, and it is a two-minute check.
Verdict
Worth it for a group that already knows it likes competitive campaign games and will commit to playing a campaign through rather than sampling a scenario. The system is quick to teach, the components need no preparation, and the arc across scenarios is where the value is.
Skip it if you want cooperative play, if your group meets irregularly, or if setup time is the thing that keeps games in the cupboard. And before ordering, open the publisher’s product page and read what is in the specific edition on sale, because in this line that varies more than it does anywhere else.
Deja un comentario